ReligiousLiberty.TV ARCHIVAL BROADSHEET PRESS Monday, November 16, 2026
Constitutional Law & Appellate DocketsArchival Print Edition

ReligiousLiberty.TV

Judge Throws Out United Methodist Lawsuit Over Departing Church’s Property, Citing Legal Double Standard

Circuit Judge Brian M. Gibbons ruled that civil courts lack authority to enforce the denomination's internal rulebook and barred the Conference from contradicting its past First Amendment defenses.


A Greenville County judge threw out a lawsuit brought by the South Carolina Conference of The United Methodist Church against a local congregation that left the denomination, ruling that civil courts cannot settle internal religious disputes and that the Conference contradicted its own past legal arguments.

Circuit Judge Brian M. Gibbons dismissed the case against the Methodist Church of Simpsonville and its pastor, Michael Smith, on November 13, 2026. The judge ruled that a religious body cannot argue in one lawsuit that civil courts must stay out of church property disputes, and then ask a civil court to step in and enforce church rules when it sues a departing congregation. The order also notes the simultaneous dismissal of 68 other consolidated lawsuits across South Carolina raising nearly identical claims.

Case: The South Carolina Conference of The United Methodist Church v. Simpsonville United Methodist Church, The Methodist Church of Simpsonville, and Michael Smith Court: State of South Carolina, County of Greenville, In the Court of Common Pleas, Thirteenth Judicial Circuit Decision date: November 13, 2026 Case number: 2024-CP-23-06475

A South Carolina trial court dismissed a lawsuit filed by the South Carolina Conference of The United Methodist Church (the Conference) to block a local congregation from leaving the denomination with its buildings and land. Judge Brian M. Gibbons granted the local church’s request to dismiss the case, denied the Conference’s request to rewrite its complaint, and canceled any legal claims (known as a notice of lis pendens) the Conference had placed on the church’s real estate titles.

The ruling resolves pretrial motions in the Greenville County case and marks the concurrent dismissal of 68 consolidated lawsuits involving other departing Methodist churches across the state.

Why Did the Church and Denomination Clash?

Founded in 1916, the Methodist Church of Simpsonville is organized as a South Carolina nonprofit corporation. After more than a decade of disagreements over church teachings within The United Methodist Church (UMC), the congregation’s governing council voted in 2024 to cut ties with the denomination.

To make the split official under state law, the local church updated its corporate registration with the state, changed its corporate name, adopted new bylaws, and filed a formal notice with the county Register of Deeds canceling trust language that had been added to a few of its property deeds in 2016.

Five months later, on November 5, 2024, the Conference sued the local church and its pastor, Michael Smith. The Conference argued that under a rule in the UMC Book of Discipline, the denomination’s governing rulebook, all local church property is held in trust for the broader denomination. The Conference asked the judge to declare the separation invalid, hand over control of the church’s property, force Pastor Smith out of the church-owned parsonage, and order him to stop talking to congregation members about leaving the UMC.

In August 2025, the South Carolina Supreme Court assigned Judge Gibbons to oversee pretrial motions for all similar Methodist property lawsuits statewide. After hearing arguments on August 31, 2026, and reviewing follow-up filings in September, Judge Gibbons dismissed the case.

Why Did the Judge Say the Conference Contradicted Itself?

A major reason Judge Gibbons dismissed the lawsuit is a legal rule called judicial estoppel. In plain English, judicial estoppel prevents a party from playing both sides of the fence in court by taking one legal position in one lawsuit and the exact opposite position in another.

Judge Gibbons pointed out that in every previous South Carolina lawsuit the court could find where the Conference was being sued, the Conference argued that the First Amendment bars civil judges from getting involved in Methodist church governance, operations, and property policies. That First Amendment protection is known as the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine, which keeps government courts out of religious disputes.

Specifically, the judge highlighted the Conference’s August 6, 2024 court filing in Stilwell et al. v. S.C. Conference of the United Methodist Church, a very similar Greenville County case. In Stilwell, a local congregation sued the Conference first, asking a judge to declare that the Conference had no legal claim to the local church’s building and land. In that case, the Conference argued that civil courts had no power to decide the dispute because it was an internal religious matter.

In the Simpsonville case, the roles were flipped: the Conference was the one suing, asking a civil judge to interpret the UMC Book of Discipline and enforce it against a local church. Relying on South Carolina legal precedent, including Quinn v. Sharon Corp. and Hayne Federal Credit Union v. Bailey, Judge Gibbons ruled that the Conference could not change its tune just because it was now the one filing the lawsuit. Because the Conference previously argued that civil courts have no authority over these disputes, it was legally barred from arguing the opposite here.

What Other Reasons Did the Judge Give for Dismissing the Case?

Even if the Conference had not contradicted its earlier court filings, Judge Gibbons ruled that the lawsuit failed on three other independent grounds:

  • The First Amendment Keeps Courts Out of Religious Rules: Under the U.S. and South Carolina constitutions, judges cannot interpret religious texts or settle disputes over church governance. Judge Gibbons noted that the Conference’s lawsuit did not rely on ordinary state property or contract laws, but instead asked the court to enforce the UMC Book of Discipline. Because civil courts lack authority over religious law, the judge had no power to hear the case or let the Conference rewrite its lawsuit.

  • The Conference Lacked Legal Standing to Sue: Under the South Carolina Nonprofit Corporation Act, a nonprofit’s board of directors has the legal authority to manage its affairs and corporate structure. State law limits who can sue to challenge a nonprofit board’s decisions to specific insiders, such as a board director, a church member filing a specialized derivative lawsuit, a trustee, the corporation itself, or the state Attorney General. Because the Conference is a separate outside organization, state law gave it no standing to challenge how Simpsonville Methodist’s board ran its corporate affairs.

  • No Valid Property Trust Existed Under State Law: Under the South Carolina Trust Code, creating a legal trust over real estate requires a signed document showing the property owner clearly intended to put the land in a trust. Most of Simpsonville Methodist’s property deeds contained no trust language at all. For the few parcels with 2016 deeds that mentioned a trust, those deeds did not state that the trust was permanent (irrevocable). Under South Carolina law, any trust that does not explicitly say it is permanent can be canceled by the owner, which Simpsonville Methodist did when its council passed a formal revocation resolution. Citing a 2022 South Carolina Supreme Court ruling involving the Episcopal Church, Judge Gibbons confirmed that simply belonging to a denomination and signing routine annual church forms does not transfer ownership of local real estate.

Commentary

Judge Gibbons’s decision exposes a common trap for national religious denominations in church property battles. When local congregations or pastors sue a denomination over leadership decisions or property rules, denominations routinely use the First Amendment like a shield, telling civil judges they have no business meddling in internal church affairs. But when a denomination goes on offense and asks a civil court to enforce its internal rulebook against a departing congregation, that same shield turns into a roadblock. As the ruling makes clear, a court’s constitutional power to hear a case cannot depend on who files paperwork at the courthouse first.

On appeal, the Conference will likely argue that asking a judge to look at real estate deeds and corporate filings is different from asking a judge to settle a theological argument. Appellate courts often look closely at judicial estoppel, especially when a party’s earlier legal argument did not lead to a final court judgment in the first lawsuit.

However, Judge Gibbons wrote the order to withstand an appeal even if a higher court narrows the estoppel ruling. By backing up his decision with the First Amendment bar, South Carolina’s nonprofit corporation rules, and the state’s strict requirements for real estate trusts, the judge placed four separate legal hurdles in the Conference’s path. In South Carolina, a local church’s real estate belongs to the local nonprofit unless the church signs clear, permanent trust paperwork that satisfies state property law.

What Happens Next

With the lawsuit dismissed, its request to amend the complaint denied, and any legal claims removed from the church’s property titles, the Conference’s remaining option is to appeal Judge Gibbons’s order to the South Carolina appellate courts.

Sources

  • The South Carolina Conference of The United Methodist Church v. Simpsonville United Methodist Church, The Methodist Church of Simpsonville, and Michael Smith, Case No. 2024-CP-23-06475, Order Granting Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss (S.C. Ct. Com. Pl., Greenville Cnty., Nov. 13, 2026).

  • Stilwell et al. v. S.C. Conference of the United Methodist Church, Case No. 2024-CP-23-03486, Answer (S.C. Ct. Com. Pl., Greenville Cnty., Aug. 6, 2024).

  • Protestant Episcopal Church in the Diocese of South Carolina v. Episcopal Church, 439 S.C. 284, 887 S.E.2d 508 (2022).

  • South Carolina Nonprofit Corporation Act, S.C. Code Ann. §§ 33-31-302, 33-31-304, 33-31-801.

  • South Carolina Trust Code, S.C. Code Ann. §§ 62-7-401, 62-7-402, 62-7-602.

If you found this breakdown helpful, like, share, and subscribe to ReligiousLiberty.TV for breaking religious liberty news and case information.

This article was assisted by AI. This does not constitute legal advice. Readers are encouraged to talk to licensed attorneys about their particular situations.

Visit ReligiousLiberty.TV for more information.