• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
ReligiousLiberty.TV / Founders' First Freedom®

ReligiousLiberty.TV / Founders' First Freedom®

religious liberty and religious freedom news

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Articles
  • Podcast
Home » Supreme Court to decide if religious hospital pensions are subject to ERISA

Supreme Court to decide if religious hospital pensions are subject to ERISA

December 5, 2016 by ReligiousLiberty.TV

 
supremecourt

Last week the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear three cases involving whether the pension plans of religiously affiliated hospital systems are exempt from federal pension funding requirements.

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) was passed to protect employees who depended on pension plans but had lost their money when their employers went out of business, or who learned too late that their employers had not properly funded their pensions. ERISA does not require employers to have pension plans, but it does regulate companies that do have pension benefits to make sure that they are paying enough into pension plans and it provides an insurance system to protect pension beneficiaries.

Churches are exempt, and since 1983 the IRS has opined that employers, like hospitals, that were started by religiously affiliated entities are also exempt. As a result, religiously-based hospitals have worked on more of an honor system when it comes to providing pension benefits to their employees even if it means that their pension plans are underfunded by millions or even billions of dollars.

Employees and plan beneficiaries who are concerned about underfunding have been filing class action suits against religious hospital systems. In the three cases the Supreme Court will hear, involving Advocate Health, Dignity Health, and St. Peter’s Healthcare System, the hospital systems have lost at the Third, Seventh, and Ninth Circuit Courts of Appeals.

In the case involving Dignity Health, the employer reportedly admitted that its administration of the pension plan did not meet ERISA requirements but that it was exempt as a “church plan” under ERISA.

The IRS understanding of the church exemption rule is a “guidance” issue rather than a law, and the circuits opinions are at odds with the way that the IRS has interpreted church plans. If the Supreme Court affirms the lower court decisions, faith-based hospitals will potentially have to pay hundreds of millions of dollars to shore up their employee pension plans to bring them to parity with those of secular employers.

The Supreme Court has consolidated all three cases for one hour of oral argument, and a date is to be set.

Early last month, Adventist Health System was hit with a separate but similar class action lawsuit in Florida federal court (Sheedy v. Adventist Health System Sunbelt Healthcare Corporation et al., number 6:2016cv01893 filed 10/28/16 in Florida Middle District Court)  by plaintiffs who claimed that their plan was short by $134 million, and that the company is a business, not a church and should be required to meet ERISA requirements. The suit seeks declaratory relief and a finding that Adventist Health System is required to bring its plan into compliance with ERISA in terms of recordkeeping and notice obligations in addition to funding to overcome the shortfall. When someone dies during the course of a medical procedure family members may be entitled to compensation.

In response, Adventist Health System has argued that it is church-related and therefore does not have to comply with ERISA because it is religious and that even if it did have to comply, the pensions are adequately funded.

A final decision in the Florida case will likely be deferred pending the result of the Supreme Court cases.

###

 

Filed Under: Current Events

Primary Sidebar

Geneva, Switzerland - December 03, 2019: World Health Organization (WHO / OMS) Headquarters - DepositPhotos.com

Biden admin could hand over US control of health emergencies to WHO next week

WASHINGTON, D.C. – The ultimate control over America’s health care and its national sovereignty will be put up for a vote next week at a meeting of the World Health Organization’s (WHO) governing legislative body, the World Health Assembly (WHA).  On May 22-28, 2022, the 75th World Health Assembly will convene at the United Nations […]

Statement on the Leak in Dobbs

The leak was intended to disrupt the processing of the decision and we are not going to dignify the leak or the unidentified leaker by analyzing it prematurely. As a constitutional republic we cannot go down that road without doing severe damage to the institution of the Supreme Court where there must be professional courtesy between the justices and their staffs.

Boston City Hall - photo from Supreme Court Opinion

Supreme Court rules 9-0 that Boston violated 1st Amendment in refusing Christian flag at City Hall

This morning the Supreme Court unanimously ruled in Shurtleff v. Boston (Dec’d 5/2/2022) that the city of Boston violated the free speech rights of a Christian group when it refused to allow them to participate in a city flag raising program.

Active Liberty - a survey of Justice Stephen Breyer's religion clause jurisprudence - Supreme Court

Active Liberty: A Survey of Justice Stephen Breyer’s Religion Clause Decisions

A comprehensive review of retiring Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer’s decisions in Free Exercise and Establishment Clause cases.

Canadian gov’t calculates that expansion of assisted suicide will save taxpayers millions of dollars

In Canada, it is easier for the disabled who do not suffer terminal illness to get approval for assisted suicide than approval for affordable housing. The government has calculated the cost of providing healthcare versus providing assisted suicide.

Random Quote

Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same.

— Ronald Reagan

Get the ReligiousLiberty.TV Newsletter!

Comes out a couple of times a month. Unsubscribe anytime automatically, no questions asked.
* = required field
unsubscribe from list

powered by MailChimp!

Copyright © 2022 Founders' First Freedom is a registered trademark. All rights reserved.

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Articles
  • Podcast
0
0
0
0