Third Circuit Tells Trial Judge to Do the RFRA Analysis Instead of Predicting How the Circuit Will Rule
In United States v.

In United States v. Devero, the Third Circuit vacated a district court’s denial of a supervised release modification request, offering a sharp reminder about the proper role of a trial court: its job is to analyze the legal framework in the first instance, not to act as a prognosticator for the appellate bench.
Dontae Devero, a practicing Rastafarian on supervised release, moved to modify his supervision conditions to allow religious marijuana use, proposing safeguards like self-reporting and regular drug testing for other substances. While praising Devero and his counsel for handling the request in good faith, the trial judge in District Court denied the motion. Rather than applying the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA), the judge noted that most reported cases rejected similar claims and stated she “cannot in good conscience predict that the Third Circuit will endorse his exception”.
The Third Circuit reversed and remanded, emphasizing that guessing how an appellate court might rule is no substitute for doing the statutory work. Under RFRA, once a claimant shows a substantial burden on a sincere religious exercise, the government must prove that applying the burden to that specific person is the least restrictive means of furthering a compelling interest.
Because RFRA demands a fact-specific inquiry into the individual’s circumstances, and because the Third Circuit had not yet ruled on this specific issues, relying on general trends in other cases involving differently situated defendants was legally insufficient. Ultimately, appellate courts rely on district courts to build the record and apply the law to the facts on the ground first, rather than skipping straight to reading appellate tea leaves.