Skip to content
September 4, 2026
Independent reporting and primary-source research on religious liberty and the First Amendment since 2008.
ReligiousLiberty.TV Law · Liberty · Conscience
Subscribe
Legal Case Library
Current Events

Substitute Teacher Loses First Amendment Challenge Over Pronoun Policy

January 30, 2026 1 min read

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a school district can require staff to use students’ preferred pronouns and maintain student privacy regarding gender identity.

TLDR

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the dismissal of Kimberly Ann Polk’s lawsuit against the Montgomery County Board of Education. Polk, a substitute teacher, alleged t…


Read more

Free Speech & Religion LGBTQ & Religious Liberty Workplace Accommodation

Holding: The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the dismissal of a substitute teacher's lawsuit challenging a school district requirement to use students' preferred pronouns and maintain student privacy regarding gender identity.