FIRST AMENDMENT • SUPREME COURT DOCKETS • APPELLATE WIRE Monday, November 16, 2026 // ARCHIVAL BROADSHEET EDITION
Constitutional Jurisprudence & Broadcast Dispatches

ReligiousLiberty.TV

U.S. APPELLATE DOCKET // LEAD DISPATCH

Judge Throws Out United Methodist Lawsuit Over Departing Church’s Property, Citing Legal Double Standard

Circuit Judge Brian M. Gibbons ruled that civil courts lack authority to enforce the denomination's internal rulebook and barred the Conference from contradicting its past First Amendment defenses.
By ReligiousLiberty.TV ReligiousLiberty.TV • November 16, 2026 • U.S. CONST. AMEND. I
Constitutional Posture & Central Question
Circuit Judge Brian M. Gibbons ruled that civil courts lack authority to enforce the denomination's internal rulebook and barred the Conference from contradicting its past First Amendment defenses.
The Wire LATEST DISPATCHES
12
Church Autonomy & Ministerial Exception

The Masterson Case and the Limits of Ecclesiastical Immunity

Oct 29, 2026 • By ReligiousLiberty.TV ReligiousLiberty.TV

Masterson had essentially proposed that the First Amendment grants a religious organization the right to manage the fallout of felony crimes internally. The court disagreed.